Coney Island Homes for Sale

Coney Island Homes for Sale

Welcome to Coney Island, a charming and vibrant subdivision nestled in the heart of Treasure Island, Florida. Known for its stunning waterfront views and laid-back atmosphere, Coney Island offers a unique blend of coastal living and community spirit that makes it an ideal place to call home.

As you stroll through the tree-lined streets of Coney Island, you'll discover a delightful variety of homes for sale, each exuding its own character and charm. From cozy beach bungalows to modern waterfront properties, there’s something to suit every lifestyle and budget. Many homes boast open floor plans, spacious backyards, and proximity to the sparkling Gulf of Mexico, making outdoor living a breeze.

Coney Island is not just about beautiful homes; it’s also about the lifestyle. Residents enjoy easy access to pristine beaches, local parks, and a plethora of recreational activities. Whether you’re an avid boater, fisherman, or simply enjoy soaking up the sun, this community has it all. Additionally, the vibrant local dining and shopping scene in Treasure Island adds to the allure, offering everything from fresh seafood restaurants to quaint boutiques.

With homes for sale in Coney Island, now is the perfect time to explore this captivating community. Experience the warmth of a close-knit neighborhood, the beauty of Florida’s coastline, and the opportunity to create lasting memories in your new home. Don’t miss out on the chance to be part of this enchanting slice of paradise!

Newest Coney Island Homes for Sale

12016 Lagoon Ln, Treasure Island
$1,600,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Coney Island SubDv. ⋅ 33706 Zip Code
Your boat out back, the beach just a short stroll away, and a tropical retreat to call your own. This beautifully updated, elevated waterfront home in the heart of Treasure Island offers access to the Intracoastal Waterway and Gulf of Mexico, with a private dock, boat lift, and jet ski lifts ready for days on the water. Featuring 3 spacious bedrooms, 2 full bathrooms, a half bathroom, and a recently transformed backyard oasis, the home brings together coastal character and inviting spaces for everyday living and entertaining. Recent improvements include a new metal roof, updated siding, new windows, and new Bahama-style shutters. Crisp white finishes, dark trim, and seafoam accents create a distinctive coastal look, complemented by palm-lined landscaping and a geometric concrete driveway with turf accents. Inside, the bright, open layout features a spacious dining area with beautiful water views and an updated kitchen with dark shaker-style cabinetry, glass-front upper cabinets, light veined countertops, stainless-steel appliances, and gold-tone accents. A generous breakfast bar provides space to gather, while vaulted ceilings and a wood-burning fireplace lend warmth and character to the living room. The main living level includes a bedroom with an en-suite bathroom. Upstairs, you’ll find the waterfront primary bedroom, a third bedroom, a full bathroom, a laundry room, and a versatile loft. Standout bathroom finishes include a glass-enclosed shower with dramatic blue tile and a warm wood vanity. The tropical backyard features newly installed artificial turf, oversized stepping pads, a palm-shaded seating nook, and an outdoor grilling station. A spacious covered patio offers room for dining and lounging, with woven pendant lighting, wood accents, and cabana-style curtains completing the relaxed coastal setting. With its unbeatable location, waterfront access, and move-in ready condition, this home offers the ultimate in coastal lifestyle living!

12016 Lagoon Ln, Treasure Island
12505 Sunshine Lane, Treasure Island
$1,675,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Coney Island SubDv. ⋅ 33706 Zip Code
Custom Coastal Retreat with Gulf & Johns Pass Views • Private Primary Suite • Wraparound Decks • Beach Access • Reinforced Construction Welcome to your private coastal retreat in the heart of Treasure Island, where relaxed beachside living meets thoughtful design, exceptional craftsmanship, and modern comfort. Lovingly maintained by the original owners, this remarkable residence stands as a testament to quality construction and pride of ownership. After purchasing the property in 1979, the owners removed the existing home and built the stunning custom residence that stands today. Engineered for peace of mind, the home is supported by reinforced concrete piers extending more than 20 feet into bedrock, providing a solid foundation. A recent 4-Point Inspection has been completed with a clean report, offering added confidence to prospective buyers. The report is attached in the MLS for review. This spacious 4 bedroom, 2 1/2 bathroom home offers an ideal blend of luxury, functionality, and effortless indoor-outdoor living. Step inside to discover a well-appointed floor plan filled with natural light and luxurious touches throughout, creating inviting spaces designed for both everyday living and entertaining. Outdoors, escape to your own resort-style setting featuring a private pool, perfect for refreshing dips after a day at the beach. For added convenience, an outdoor shower with hot water is perfectly positioned poolside. Just off the Primary Suite is an expansive bonus room that can serve as a private office, reading retreat, fitness space, or third-story sitting area with elevated views. The primary bathroom features dual vanities, a walk-in closet, and access to a large attic storage area. The main living level offers three bedrooms, an updated bathroom, spacious living room with custom bookcases, bedroom that easily could be a Florida room/den, and a formal dining room. The upgraded kitchen features include granite countertops, wood cabinetry, breakfast counter seating, and a separate pantry/laundry room. Expansive wraparound decking creates exceptional indoor-outdoor entertaining space. The oversized 2-car garage is complemented by a dedicated workbench and storage for jet skis, or golf cart. A versatile bonus room off the garage has its own bathroom, offering endless possibilities as home office, creative studio, fitness room, or guest overflow space. Multiple decks invite you to relax and enjoy gentle coastal breezes and serene water views, delivering the ambiance of waterfront living without the premium. The crown jewel is the third-story balcony, showcasing beautiful views of the Gulf and the boats entering and departing from Historic Johns Pass. It's the perfect backdrop for morning coffee, afternoon relaxation, or spectacular sunset evenings. Ideally located, you can stroll to Johns Pass to enjoy waterfront dining, boutique shopping, entertainment, and boating adventures just moments from your door. Whether you're seeking a full-time residence, or a prime investment opportunity, this Treasure Island gem captures the very best of Florida coastal living — exceptional construction, breathtaking views, an unbeatable location, and a lifestyle that's second to none. Be sure to check out the video tour and experience everything this extraordinary home has to offer!

12505 Sunshine Lane, Treasure Island
108 125th Avenue, Treasure Island
$1,050,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Coney Island SubDv. ⋅ 33706 Zip Code
Pre-Construction. To be built. WELCOME to an EXCEPTIONAL GULF COAST LIFESTYLE Opportunity in one of the area's MOST SOUGHT-AFTER Beach Destinations steps away from TREASURE ISLAND BEACH & JOHN'S PASS. Set on an EXPANSIVE 59' X 105' LOT w/ more than 6,000 SQ FT, this pre-construction residence offers the rare combination of a Thoughtfully Designed NEW HOME w/ GENEROUS OUTDOOR SPACE in an UNBEATABLE LOCATION just a short walk to the Soft, White Sands of Treasure Island Beach & John's Pass Village is just a short stroll away. This Iconic Waterfront Destination offers more than 120 shops, restaurants, entertainment venues, exciting water activities from dolphin tours, tiki cruises to parasailing & jet-ski adventures. DESIGNED for COASTAL LIVING, the SEA HAWKE by SEASAFE HOMES delivers approx. 1,147 sq ft of EFFICIENTLY DESIGNED LIVING SPACE, featuring 3 Bedrooms & 2 Baths. Its OPEN-CONCEPT layout creates an INVITING FLOW between the KITCHEN, DINING, & LIVING AREAS ideal for relaxed everyday living, entertaining guests, or enjoying your own PRIVATE COASTAL RETREAT. The KITCHEN offers MODERN FINISHES, GENEROUS STORAGE & a practical layout that MAXIMIZES the home's compact footprint. The PRIVATE PRIMARY SUITE provides a PEACEFUL RETREAT w/ a SPACIOUS BEDROOM, WELL-APPOINTED BATH, & WALK-IN CLOSET. Two additional Bedrooms offer flexibility for family, guests, a home office, or personal space. Built w/ COASTAL RESILIENCE in mind SEASAFE HOMES incorporates CONSTRUCTION FEATURES specifically designed for Florida's Coastal Environment, including a ROBUST 2X12 FLOOR SYSTEM & 2X6 EXTERIOR WALLS. The SEA HAWKE is ENGINEERED for WIND SPEEDS of up to 180 MPH, EXCEEDING the typical 150-MPH standard referenced in the listing. SEASAFE's Two-Site Building Process is Designed to STREAMLINE CONSTRUCTION and can REDUCE BUILD TIMES BY UP TO 75% compared with traditional site-built construction, helping MINIMIZE the amount of TIME your new home is EXPOSED to the ELEMENTS during Construction. IMAGINE starting your MORNING with a WALK along the BEACH, spending the afternoon on the WATER & ending the day with DINNER AND ENTERTAINMENT at John's Pass ALL w/ in EASY REACH of your HOME. When you WANT even MORE, downtown St. Petersburg is just a short drive away, offering the St. Pete Pier, Renowned Museums including The Dalí & Chihuly Collections, Vibrant Arts & Culture, Professional Sports & Concert Venues & an Impressive Selection of Restaurants. With more than 6,000 sq ft of land, there's also room to CREATE your own PRIVATE OUTDOOR OASIS, including the potential for a pool, subject to plans, permitting & applicable requirements. Whether you're looking for a PRIMARY Residence, a Coastal GETAWAY, or a property in a PREMIER BEACHSIDE location, this opportunity combines NEW construction, MODERN coastal living, exceptional DURABILITY, and an ENVIABLE Treasure Island LOCATION. And if the SEA HAWKE isn't quite the right fit, SEASAFE HOMES offers 11 additional pre-engineered floor plans, giving you the Flexibility to choose a Design that better matches your Lifestyle & Vision. MAKE THIS YOUR GULF COAST ESCAPE! Build New. Live Coastal. Walk to the Beach. EXPERIENCE everything Treasure Island & the Gulf Coast have to offer RIGHT HERE, RIGHT NOW & Waiting for YOU!

108 125th Avenue, Treasure Island
12201 Gulf Boulevard, Treasure Island
$1,095,000
5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Coney Island SubDv. ⋅ 33706 Zip Code
5-bedroom, 3-bath luxury coastal residence located less than 800 feet from Treasure Island beach, offering an elevated blend of personal retreat and income-producing potential. Refined, light-filled living and dining spaces create a sophisticated setting for entertaining, anchored by a well-appointed kitchen with generous storage and prep areas. The bedroom configuration is designed for comfort and privacy, featuring a serene primary suite complemented by spacious guest rooms to accommodate families and larger groups. Thoughtfully curated outdoor areas capture the coastal lifestyle, with inviting spaces to lounge, dine, and unwind after a day on the sand. With its scale, polished finishes, and premier proximity to the shoreline, this property functions equally well as an upscale primary residence, luxury vacation home, or high-performing short-term rental. Currently operating as a very profitable income-producing short-term rental.

12201 Gulf Boulevard, Treasure Island
115 124th Avenue W, Treasure Island
$1,400,000
6 Beds ⋅ 6 Baths ⋅ Coney Island SubDv. ⋅ 33706 Zip Code
LEGAL WEEKLY RENTAL DUPLEX just steps from the sugar-white sands of Treasure Island. This unique income-producing property is being offered as the entire duplex featuring 6 bedrooms, 5 full baths and 2 half baths with 2,252 square feet of living space (2,863 gross square feet). Each side of the property functions as a private rental unit (A & B), while an adjoining interior hallway with locking doors allows both units to be opened and combined, creating one large residence ideal for large groups, family retreats, or maximizing vacation rental income. Recent improvements include all new flooring throughout both units, brand new appliances and cabinetry in each kitchen, and fresh interior paint throughout. Located on a quiet island street approximately 100 steps to the beach, with easy access to restaurants, boating, fishing, and everything that makes Treasure Island one of Florida’s most desirable Gulf Coast destinations. An exceptional opportunity for vacation rental investors or buyers seeking a flexible beach property with strong income potential.

115 124th Avenue W, Treasure Island
Start Your Search

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!